Hardwood Flooring in Indianapolis, IN from Brothers Floor Covering

Which Hardwood Flooring Is the Most Durable?

Hardwood floors are a timeless addition to any home, offering classic beauty and lasting value. But with so many varieties available, choosing the most durable option can be a challenge. 


Understanding hardwood durability

Several factors influence a hardwood floor's ability to withstand everyday wear and tear. Here are the key ones to consider:


  • Janka Hardness Test: This industry standard measures the force required to drive a steel ball halfway into the wood. Higher Janka ratings indicate greater resistance to dents and scratches.
  • Species: Different wood species naturally possess varying degrees of hardness. For example, hickory boasts exceptional strength, while softer woods like pine are more susceptible to damage.
  • Construction: Solid hardwood planks are the most durable, but engineered hardwood offers good stability and can be more resistant to moisture fluctuations.
  • Finish: A high-quality finish protects the wood from scratches, stains, and fading. Consider scratch-resistant polyurethane or aluminum oxide finishes for high-traffic areas.


Top contenders for durable hardwood flooring


Hickory reigns supreme among domestic hardwoods, boasting an impressive Janka rating around 1820. This translates to exceptional resistance to dents, scratches, and everyday wear and tear. Hickory's unique grain pattern also helps to camouflage minor imperfections. However, its distinctive rustic look might not suit all design preferences.


Brazilian walnut (Ipe)

If ultimate durability is your priority, Brazilian walnut (ipe) stands out. This exotic wood boasts a staggering Janka rating of 3680, making it one of the hardest flooring options on the market. Ipe offers a deep, rich color and a beautiful grain pattern. When considering this option, ensure you purchase from FSC-certified retailers to promote sustainable forestry practices.



A popular choice for its light and airy aesthetic, maple also delivers on durability. With a Janka rating around 1450, it can withstand moderate to high traffic. Maple's tight grain pattern helps to minimize the appearance of scratches, making it a versatile option for various design styles.


White oak

Another highly sought-after choice, white oak offers a classic look with a Janka rating of approximately 1360. This translates to good resistance to dents and scratches. White oak's subtle grain pattern hides imperfections well, making it a great choice for busy households. Additionally, white oak comes in various stain options, allowing you to customize the look to match your décor.


Other factors to consider

Beyond pure durability, there are other factors to weigh in when choosing hardwood flooring:


  • Lifestyle: Consider your activity level and whether you have pets. If you have a busy household with children and pets, prioritize species like hickory or Brazilian walnut.
  • Moisture resistance: Engineered hardwood can be a good choice for areas with potential moisture exposure, such as kitchens or basements.
  • Maintenance: All hardwood floors require regular cleaning and occasional refinishing. Consider the level of maintenance you're comfortable with.


Finding the perfect fit for your space

There's no single "most durable" hardwood floor – the ideal choice depends on your specific needs and preferences. By considering factors like Janka rating, species, construction, finish, and your lifestyle, you can make an informed decision that will bring beauty and lasting value to your home.


Elevate your home with Brothers Floor Covering

At Brothers Floor Covering, our knowledgeable staff is passionate about helping you find the perfect hardwood flooring for your home. We offer a wide selection of high-quality, durable hardwood options.

Our conveniently located showroom in Indianapolis, IN, serves Indianapolis, Zionsville, Carmel, Westfield, and Geist. Visit us today to explore our extensive collection and discuss your project with our flooring experts. Let Brothers Floor Covering transform your vision into a reality!